Previous post: Topology Optimization Next post: Ray Casting in the Browser With Learned Maps

What Shape Cuts Drag? Breeding the Teardrop

A blunt 100 mm slab at fixed area starts at Cd 1.15. Seeded breeding tapers the tail over 200 rounds and lands on a teardrop near Cd 0.05.

Overview

A body must pass through air and air pushes back. Start is fixed: a 100 mm body with 2200 mm² area, drawn as half-widths at 12 stations. It starts as the worst case, a flat slab at Cd 1.15. Press Run and breeding trims the tail over 200 rounds: 24 shapes per round, best 4 as parents, until a teardrop near Cd 0.05 stays. Same area, same length, about one-twentieth the drag.

Gray shows the slab. Amber shows the shaped body. Bars show drag. A curve shows best drag by round. Stop halts. Replay restarts. Reduced-motion mode jumps to the end.

The hero draws dotted paths around the body. They show flow in sketch form. They churn behind the slab and lie flat behind the winner. The charts hold the numbers, not the sketch.

Why the Tail Rules

Drag on a blunt body comes mostly from the wake, not the skin. The nose parts air cleanly. The bill comes at the tail, where flow must close behind. A slab ends in a wall. Flow quits, splits off, and leaves a wide churn wake at low pressure that drags back. A tapered tail lets flow rejoin bit by bit. The wake narrows. Pull-back drops.

The score rule matches this: squared tail width counts most, squared nose width counts less, plus a small skin term. Full ends pay near 1.15 like a flat plate. Near-closed ends near 0.05 like a teardrop.

Fixed Area Rule

Score is minus drag and nothing else. Without a size lock the search would win by shrinking to a needle. Less body, less drag, a score win with no craft. Each shape rescales to 2200 mm² before scoring. Length stays fixed too. The only way to win is to reshape: where to place area along 100 mm, full nose or full middle, fast taper or slow.

The Breed

Each step adds random noise per station, blends with neighbors so jagged teeth die out, clamps to 1–20 mm half-width, and rescales to fixed area. The run is seeded and bit-same in tests and widget. The winner pinches both ends to about 6% of peak width. Best drag falls from 0.53 in the first mix to 0.05 at round 200. Shape locks in the first 40 rounds. Later rounds polish.

Checks

Seeded replay gives same path each time. Slab holds fixed area. Mutants stay in bounds at fixed area. Slab scores in the flat-plate band near 1.0–1.2. Tapered tails score far lower. Far field reads clean with a wake dip behind the slab. Winner beats slab by more than half with a tapered valid body. Step mode matches full runs.

Honest Limits

A rank proxy, not a tunnel. The number orders shapes. It does not certify one. Real drag adds speed effects, trip and roughness, and 3D ends. None live here. The flow sketch is dotted paths with wake wobble scaled by drag, not a solved field. The 0.05 winner is best for the proxy at fixed area and length, not for steel or carbon.

References

  • Anderson, John D. 2017. Fundamentals of Aerodynamics. 6th ed. McGraw-Hill.
  • Hoerner, Sighard F. 1965. Fluid-Dynamic Drag. Hoerner Fluid Dynamics.
  • Schlichting, Hermann, and Klaus Gersten. 2017. Boundary-Layer Theory. 9th ed. Springer.